Read more on jimlivingstone.com.au

The ADHD Identity Trap

The Hidden Mirror: How Your Beliefs Shape Your ADHD Identity (And Vice Versa)

Your brain works differently. You've probably heard this about ADHD countless times, but here's what fewer people talk about: the intricate dance between who you believe you are and who you become. For ADHD minds, this relationship between identity and beliefs creates a particularly powerful feedback loop that can either propel you forward or keep you stuck in patterns that no longer serve you.

What Comes First: The Identity-Belief Chicken or Egg?

Before exploring the interaction between beliefs and identity, it's essential to understand their developmental relationship. In early childhood, your foundational identity takes precedence—you're born with a basic sense of self that encompasses your temperament, neurological wiring, and core personality traits. If you have ADHD, this means you arrived in the world with high energy, intense emotions, creative thinking patterns, and different attention regulation. This foundational identity influenced what you paid attention to and how you interpreted your earliest experiences.

But then, usually around ages 2-4, when language develops and social feedback becomes more complex, beliefs take over as the primary driver of identity formation. This is where the plot often thickens for neurodivergent children, as their beliefs are typically based on how well they fit into neurotypical expectations rather than an understanding of their unique neurological gifts.

The Stories We Tell Ourselves

Every day, your brain processes thousands of experiences through the lens of these established beliefs. When you have ADHD, these beliefs often get shaped by years of feedback that can feel overwhelmingly negative. "You're disorganised." "You don't pay attention." "You're too much." Over time, these external messages crystallise into internal beliefs that become part of your evolved identity.

The tricky part? Once these beliefs take root, they start influencing how you interpret new experiences. That time you forgot an important deadline isn't just a mistake—it becomes evidence that you're "unreliable." When you hyperfocus on a creative project for six hours straight, you might dismiss it as "just getting distracted again" rather than recognising it as a superpower in action.

This is what psychologists call confirmation bias, and ADHD brains are particularly susceptible to it because we tend to remember negative feedback more intensely than positive feedback. Our rejection sensitivity dysphoria amplifies criticism while our brain's tendency toward black-and-white thinking makes us more likely to generalise single incidents into sweeping identity statements.

The ADHD Identity Trap

Many people with ADHD find themselves caught in what I call the "identity trap"—a cycle where limiting beliefs about ADHD create a narrow sense of self, which then influences behaviour in ways that seem to confirm those original beliefs. For example, if you believe that having ADHD means you're inherently disorganised, you might not invest time in developing organisational systems because "what's the point?" This lack of systems then leads to more disorganisation, reinforcing the original belief.

The identity trap is particularly insidious because it operates below conscious awareness. You're not actively choosing to think "I am disorganised"—it just feels like an obvious fact about yourself. These beliefs become so deeply ingrained in your sense of self that questioning them can feel like questioning your entire identity.

But here's what's liberating about understanding this cycle: beliefs are not facts. They're interpretations of experiences, and interpretations can change. When you recognise that your current identity is largely a collection of beliefs you've accepted about yourself, you suddenly have the power to examine those beliefs and choose which ones actually serve you.

The Neuroscience of Belief and Identity

Your ADHD brain is constantly seeking patterns and making predictions about the world. When you hold a belief about yourself, your brain actively looks for evidence to support that belief while filtering out contradictory information. This isn't a character flaw—it's how all human brains work. The challenge for ADHD minds is that our pattern-seeking can become hypervigilant around negative self-concepts.

Neuroscientist Dr. Joe Dispenza explains that our personality is essentially a set of thoughts, behaviours, and emotions that we repeat so often that they become automatic. For people with ADHD, many of these automatic patterns were formed during childhood and adolescence, when we were still learning to navigate a world not designed for our neurotype.

The good news? Neuroplasticity research shows that our brains remain changeable throughout our lives. When you consciously choose new thoughts and behaviours that align with who you want to become rather than who you think you are, you literally rewire your brain's neural pathways.

The Liberating Truth About Malleability

Here's what's genuinely liberating about understanding this developmental sequence: while your core neurological wiring isn't going to fundamentally change, your beliefs about what that wiring means for your capabilities, worth, and potential can transform completely. Your ADHD brain structure remains constant, but the belief systems that have grown up around your identity? Those are remarkably malleable.

Many adults with ADHD discover that beliefs they've carried for decades—like "I'm lazy" or "I can't be trusted with important tasks"—were never accurate assessments of their character. They were simply misunderstandings of how their brain works, formed during a time when neurodivergence was poorly understood.

This means that beliefs, not your fundamental identity, are your most accessible point of intervention in breaking limiting cycles. You can't rewire your basic neurology, but you have tremendous power to examine and reshape the belief systems that determine how you interpret and respond to your ADHD traits.

Rewriting Your Internal Narrative

Changing deep-seated beliefs about yourself isn't about positive thinking or pretending your challenges don't exist. It's about developing a more nuanced, accurate understanding of who you are that includes both your struggles and your strengths.

Start by becoming curious about your automatic thoughts. When you make a mistake, what story do you immediately tell yourself? Is it "I always mess things up" or "That didn't go as planned, what can I learn?" The first story reinforces an identity of incompetence; the second reinforces an identity of someone who grows through experience.

Pay attention to the language you use when describing yourself to others. Do you lead with your deficits ("I'm terrible at remembering names") or do you present a balanced picture ("I sometimes struggle with names, but I'm great at remembering faces and connecting ideas")? The words you choose both reflect and reinforce your internal beliefs about yourself.

Consider also examining the sources of your beliefs. Many adults with ADHD carry beliefs that were formed during childhood based on feedback from people who didn't understand neurodivergence. A teacher's frustration with your fidgeting wasn't a character assessment—it was a reflection of their own limitations in working with different learning styles.

The Power of Identity-First Thinking

Instead of asking "What should I do?" try asking "What would someone with the identity I want to embody do in this situation?" This subtle shift moves you from problem-focused thinking to identity-based decision making.

If you want to see yourself as someone who follows through on commitments, you start making choices that align with that identity. You might invest in a planning system not because you're disorganised, but because organised people use tools to support their success. You might ask for deadline reminders not because you're forgetful, but because reliable people create systems to ensure they meet their obligations.

This approach works particularly well for ADHD minds because it gives us a clear framework for decision-making. Instead of relying on motivation or willpower (both notoriously unreliable for us), you operate from a stable sense of identity that guides your choices, even when emotions fluctuate.

Moving Forward

The relationship between your beliefs and your identity isn't fixed—it's dynamic and constantly evolving. Every day, you have opportunities to choose thoughts and actions that either reinforce old limiting beliefs or support the emergence of a more empowered sense of self.

Remember that this process isn't about perfection. Your ADHD brain will still have challenges, and you'll still make mistakes. The difference lies in how you interpret those experiences. When you see setbacks as information rather than confirmation of inadequacy, you maintain the flexibility to keep growing and evolving.

Your identity is not your limitation—it's your launching pad. When you align your beliefs with your potential rather than your past, you create space for a version of yourself that might surprise you with what it's capable of achieving.

To help you alter your beliefs grab a copy of the Belief Change Worksheet

Want to share this newsletter issue via text, social media, or email? Just copy and paste this link: https://jims-newsletter-51b782.beehiiv.com/p/88510921-5e17-41ac-aabe-fbeec9dae202?draft=true

Download your complimentary PDF of the first two chapters.

Download your complimentary PDF of the first couple of chapters.

Or, if you want to buy a copy. 

Expect the Best,

If you’ve got a second, I would love to hear your thoughts and comments. [email protected]  I reply to every email.

This site is not intended to provide and does not constitute medical, legal, or other professional advice. The content in this newsletter is designed to support, not replace, medical or psychiatric treatment. Please seek professional help if you believe you may have Mental Health Issues.